Bovine collagen and marine collagen are both common collagen supplements, and they are both thought to be beneficial for skin, joints, and other connective tissues. Nonetheless, there are some differences between them in terms of their sources, production methods, and more. To make it more understandable, we will explore the differences between bovine collagen and marine collagen in this article.
01 Source
vBovine Collagen: Bovine collagen usually comes from parts of the cow such as skin, bone or cartilage. These parts are rich in collagen and are the main source of collagen extracted from cattle. During the preparation process, these parts usually undergo a series of processing steps including cleaning, heating, and hydrolysis to extract and process them into a final collagen product such as powder or capsule form.
vMarine Collagen: Sources of marine collagen are usually marine animal skin, fish scales, fish skin, fish bones, or tissues from other marine organisms. Common sources of marine collagen include deep-sea fish (e.g., shark, cod, trout, etc.), seaweed, and marine shellfish. These marine organisms are often considered to be rich in collagen and are processed and treated during extraction and processing in areas such as their skin, fish scales or fish bones to extract pure marine collagen. The extraction and processing often requires special techniques to ensure the purity and quality of the product.
02 Production Method
Bovine collagen and marine collagen may be produced differently in some respects, but in general both require a series of processing steps to extract and prepare them into the final product. Below is a general comparison of their production processes.
vBovine Collagen: Techniques such as heating, hydrolysis and filtration may be involved to isolate pure collagen and process it into forms such as powders or capsules. May involve the breeding and slaughtering of cattle, with some environmental impact, especially when produced on a large scale. May have certain odors and tastes, depending on the techniques and conditions used in the extraction and processing.
vMarine Collagen: The same techniques of heating, hydrolysis and filtration are required to extract collagen from marine biological tissues and process it into the final product. The extraction of marine collagen may have an impact on living marine resources, and there is a need to ensure the rational use of marine resources and avoid overfishing to ensure environmental sustainability. Due to its origin, it may have different odors and tastes, which may vary depending on the type of product and processing method.
03 Nutritional Composition
Bovine collagen and marine collagen may have some slight differences in their nutritional content, depending on their source and how they are produced. In general, they are both good sources of protein and contain some supporting nutrients.
vBovine Collagen: In general, bovine collagen has a relatively high protein content. It may contain collagen types I and III, which are found mainly in skin, bone and cartilage. May contain some micronutrients associated with bovine skin or bone, such as calcium and selenium.
vMarine Collagen: Marine collagen is also rich in protein, but the exact amount may vary depending on the source. The specific type of collagen contained may vary, but usually includes types I and III. It may contain nutrients that are specific to marine organisms, such as marine minerals and algal nutrients.
04 Bioavailability
Both types of collagen have great absorption rates thanks to the process of breaking down the collagen.
vBovine Collagen: Bovine Collagen still has an excellent absorption rate, with 90% of peptides being absorbed just a few hours after consuming it. Regardless of your collagen choice, you can enjoy a great absorption rate as studies have shown that ingesting collagen allows it to be absorbed and used by the body so much more efficiently than simply applying it to skin.
vMarine Collagen: Marine Collagen is broken down into slightly smaller particles and studies have found that it is absorbed 1.5 times more efficiently than other types of collagen.
05 Potential Benefits
vGut health: Both marine and bovine collagen help repair our intestinal lining. Sometimes referred to as the “superfood of gut health,” collagen is the Superhero for any digestive diseases. Basically, it infuses the gut lining with its ample amino acids, and this helps repair any gaps in the lining.
vSkin and hair health: Bovine and Marine collagens are great for several reasons. Most notably, it improves skin and hair health. Since our natural collagen production decreases with age and sun exposure, this often shows up in our skin.
vBone Health: Bovine collagen, with its higher concentration of type I and type III collagen, is often favored for bone health due to its role in bone formation and strength. However, marine collagen may still contribute to bone health through its calcium-binding properties and support for collagen synthesis.
In conclusion, both bovine and marine collagen provide the same benefits. Both are great for skin, hair, gut, and bone health. The deciding factor comes down to your personal preferences, dietary restrictions, and health concerns, like allergies.
By reading an article such as this one, however, you´ve taken a big step toward becoming a more informed consumer and are now empowered with the information you need to make the right choice for yourself!
Soybean protein isolate VS whey protein, which one is better?
Astaxanthin vs CoQ10
